Redis vs Memcached
2026年选择正确工具的详细比较
🏆 快速判定
胜者: Redis
Redis is the more versatile choice for most use cases, offering rich data structures, persistence, and pub/sub. Memcached excels as a pure, high-performance cache when simplicity is key.
📚 Explore More
📊 Visual Comparison
总体评分比较
分类细分
Redis 亮点
- ✅ Rich data structures (lists, sets, sorted sets, hashes)
- ✅ Built-in persistence options (RDB, AOF)
- 💰 Free (self-hosted) / varies managed
Memcached 亮点
- ✅ Extremely simple and lightweight
- ✅ Multi-threaded architecture
- 💰 Free (self-hosted) / varies managed
功能比较
| Feature | Redis | Memcached |
|---|---|---|
| Data Structures | Strings, Lists, Sets, Hashes, Sorted Sets, Streams | Strings only |
| Persistence | RDB snapshots + AOF | ✗ |
| Replication | Master-replica | No built-in |
| Clustering | Redis Cluster | Client-side sharding |
| Pub/Sub | ✓ | ✗ |
| Lua Scripting | ✓ | ✗ |
| TTL Support | ✓ | ✓ |
| Transactions | MULTI/EXEC | ✗ |
| Modules | RedisJSON, RediSearch, etc. | ✗ |
| Max Value Size | 512MB | 1MB (default) |
什么是Redis？
Redis is an open-source, in-memory data structure store used as a database, cache, message broker, and streaming engine. It supports rich data structures beyond simple key-value pairs.
✅优点
- •Rich data structures (lists, sets, sorted sets, hashes)
- •Built-in persistence options (RDB, AOF)
- •Pub/Sub messaging support
- •Lua scripting for complex operations
- •Cluster mode for horizontal scaling
- •Active community and ecosystem
❌缺点
- •Higher memory usage than Memcached
- •Single-threaded for commands (I/O is multi-threaded since v6)
- •Licensing changes with Redis Ltd
- •More complex configuration
- •Persistence can impact performance
什么是Memcached？
Memcached is a high-performance, distributed memory object caching system designed for speeding up dynamic web applications by alleviating database load. It's simple, fast, and battle-tested.
✅优点
- •Extremely simple and lightweight
- •Multi-threaded architecture
- •Lower memory overhead per key
- •Predictable performance
- •Mature and battle-tested at scale
- •Easy horizontal scaling
❌缺点
- •Only supports simple key-value strings
- •No built-in persistence
- •No pub/sub or messaging
- •No built-in replication
- •Limited max value size (1MB default)
- •Less active development
价格比较
Redis
Free (self-hosted) / varies managed
Open source + managed services
✓ 提供免费版View detailed pricing →Memcached
Free (self-hosted) / varies managed
Open source + managed services
✓ 提供免费版View detailed pricing →📊深度分析: Redis vs Memcached
在Redis和Memcached之间做选择可能很困难，因为两个工具都为现代工作流程提供了吸引人的功能。在这个全面的比较中，我们将分析从功能和定价到实际用例的各个方面，帮助您做出明智的决定。
Redis
Redis is an open-source, in-memory data structure store used as a database, cache, message broker, and streaming engine. It supports rich data structures beyond simple key-value pairs.
Memcached
Memcached is a high-performance, distributed memory object caching system designed for speeding up dynamic web applications by alleviating database load. It's simple, fast, and battle-tested.
🎯最佳使用场景
何时选择Redis
- ✓适合团队:
Rich data structures (lists, sets, sorted sets, hashes)
- ✓适合小型企业:
Built-in persistence options (RDB, AOF)
- ✓适合大企业:
Pub/Sub messaging support
何时选择Memcached
- ✓适合个人:
Extremely simple and lightweight
- ✓适合小型企业:
Multi-threaded architecture
- ✓适合团队:
Lower memory overhead per key
🔍功能深入分析
Data Structures
Persistence
Replication
Clustering
Pub/Sub
Lua Scripting
💰定价分析
Redis
Open source + managed services
✅ Free tier availableMemcached
Open source + managed services
✅ Free tier available💡 Pro Tip
Both tools offer free trials or tiers. We recommend testing both with your actual workflow before committing to a paid plan.
🏆我们的推荐
经过广泛的分析和测试，这是我们的看法：Redis和Memcached都是能够显著提高生产力的优秀工具。最佳选择取决于您的具体需求、工作流程和优先级。
Choose Redis if:
You need rich data structures, persistence, pub/sub messaging, or want a versatile in-memory data store beyond simple caching.
Choose Memcached if:
You only need simple key-value caching, want lower memory overhead, or need multi-threaded performance for high-throughput caching.
常见问题
For simple key-value operations, performance is comparable. Memcached can be slightly faster for pure caching due to its multi-threaded architecture, but the difference is negligible for most applications.
最终结论：您应该选择哪个？
✨ 选择Redis，如果
You need rich data structures, persistence, pub/sub messaging, or want a versatile in-memory data store beyond simple caching.
✨ 选择Memcached，如果
You only need simple key-value caching, want lower memory overhead, or need multi-threaded performance for high-throughput caching.