pnpm vs npm
2026年选择正确工具的详细比较
📚 Explore More
📊 Visual Comparison
总体评分比较
分类细分
pnpm 亮点
- ✅ Significantly faster installations
- ✅ Saves disk space with content-addressable store
- 💰 Free
npm 亮点
- ✅ Default with Node.js (zero setup)
- ✅ Largest package registry (2M+ packages)
- 💰 Free / Pro $7/month
功能比较
| Feature | pnpm | npm |
|---|---|---|
| Speed | 2-3x faster than npm | Baseline |
| Disk Usage | Content-addressable store | Duplicates per project |
| Monorepo | Built-in workspace support | Basic workspaces |
| Lock File | pnpm-lock.yaml | package-lock.json |
| Security | Strict by default | npm audit |
| Phantom Dependencies | Prevented | Allowed (hoisting) |
| Plug'n'Play | ✗ | ✗ |
| Workspaces | Native | Basic |
| Scripts | pnpm run (with filtering) | npm run |
| Corepack | Supported | Supported |
什么是pnpm？
pnpm is a fast, disk-space efficient package manager for JavaScript/Node.js. It uses a content-addressable store and hard links to save disk space and speed up installations.
✅优点
- •Significantly faster installations
- •Saves disk space with content-addressable store
- •Strict dependency resolution (no phantom deps)
- •Built-in monorepo support
- •Compatible with npm ecosystem
- •Efficient CI caching
❌缺点
- •Smaller community than npm
- •Some packages have compatibility issues
- •Hard links can confuse some tools
- •Different node_modules structure
- •Learning curve for monorepo features
- •Less documentation than npm
什么是npm？
npm is the default package manager for Node.js and the world's largest software registry. With over 2 million packages, it's the foundation of the JavaScript ecosystem.
✅优点
- •Default with Node.js (zero setup)
- •Largest package registry (2M+ packages)
- •Universal compatibility
- •Extensive documentation
- •Most tutorials and examples use npm
- •GitHub-owned with strong backing
❌缺点
- •Slower installations than alternatives
- •Duplicates packages across projects
- •node_modules can be huge
- •Phantom dependency issues
- •Monorepo support is basic
- •Security audit can be noisy
价格比较
📊深度分析: pnpm vs npm
在pnpm和npm之间做选择可能很困难，因为两个工具都为现代工作流程提供了吸引人的功能。在这个全面的比较中，我们将分析从功能和定价到实际用例的各个方面，帮助您做出明智的决定。
pnpm
pnpm is a fast, disk-space efficient package manager for JavaScript/Node.js. It uses a content-addressable store and hard links to save disk space and speed up installations.
npm
npm is the default package manager for Node.js and the world's largest software registry. With over 2 million packages, it's the foundation of the JavaScript ecosystem.
🎯最佳使用场景
何时选择pnpm
- ✓适合团队:
Significantly faster installations
- ✓适合小型企业:
Saves disk space with content-addressable store
- ✓适合大企业:
Strict dependency resolution (no phantom deps)
何时选择npm
- ✓适合个人:
Default with Node.js (zero setup)
- ✓适合小型企业:
Largest package registry (2M+ packages)
- ✓适合团队:
Universal compatibility
🔍功能深入分析
Speed
Disk Usage
Monorepo
Lock File
Security
Phantom Dependencies
💰定价分析
pnpm
Open source
✅ Free tier availablenpm
Open source + npm Pro
✅ Free tier available💡 Pro Tip
Both tools offer free trials or tiers. We recommend testing both with your actual workflow before committing to a paid plan.
🏆我们的推荐
经过广泛的分析和测试，这是我们的看法：pnpm和npm都是能够显著提高生产力的优秀工具。最佳选择取决于您的具体需求、工作流程和优先级。
Choose pnpm if:
You want faster installs, care about disk space, work with monorepos, or want to prevent phantom dependency issues.
Choose npm if:
You want zero setup with Node.js, maximum compatibility, or are following tutorials and examples that use npm.
常见问题
Yes, pnpm uses the same npm registry and is compatible with virtually all npm packages. The main difference is how it structures node_modules.
最终结论：您应该选择哪个？
✨ 选择pnpm，如果
You want faster installs, care about disk space, work with monorepos, or want to prevent phantom dependency issues.
✨ 选择npm，如果
You want zero setup with Node.js, maximum compatibility, or are following tutorials and examples that use npm.